Idiot Country
Posted by Blue Man on 10 Apr 2008 at 06:40 pm | Tagged as: Games, Rants
Because I surround myself entirely with excellent folk I sometimes forget that gaming is a pastime primarily enjoyed by affluent young males.
Actually, that’s not really true. Most of my Live friends list are affluent young males. The websites I frequent are largely made and populated by affluent young males. I’M a (fairly) affluent young(ish) male (yeah, I’ve checked). I don’t forget that that demographic dominates gaming at all.
What I forget is that gaming is a hobby largely enjoyed by fucking idiots.
Because I hang about with a better class of gamer I generally burble along decently isolated from the hoards of braying, spoiled, clueless berks carting around a sense of entitlement to rival Violet Elizabeth Bott’s.
Which is why it’s always a shock when something bursts my bubble, then beats me around the head and body with a big sockful of “Oh Yeah, Most People Are Complete Wankers, Aren’t They?” Venturing out into the murky jungle of public online gaming is usually good for this, as is trying to read the comments appended to Eurogamer articles by the hoi polloi.
Here’s a f’rinstance. A developer complains that too many black characters in games are “urban” stereotypes, reinforcing casual racism. Pretty undeniable, I’d have thought. Games still largely filter themselves through the perceived expectations of young white males and so generally treat race in about as enlightened a fashion as they treat women. Yes, of course there are exceptions but they remain just that.
Some selected highlights from the comments section attached to that article, then.
“Tell me this is a joke.”
“Anyone who playes on Xbox Live and hears the Americans knows that this is a reality, not just a stereotype. Anyone offended by it is a complete moron.”
“He’s entitled to his opinion I guess. I can just imagine what his whining sounds like. Bet he sounds really pissy. One of those people you meet and immediately want to punch the crap out of. No?”
“He should go make a game with a main black character who doesn’t “talk black” instead of bitching about it, Mr Victim Complex, stereotyping is good, most of the time it ends up being true anyway otherwise why would we do it on instinct?”
“Well he has to be a tit if he takes Gears of war seriously. Idiot. I quite liked the Cole Train character in Gears, he made me laugh.”
“I quite liked The Black And White Minstrel Show, it made me laugh.”
“Shut the fuck up you whining prick”
“What would a non-stereotypical black person look like?”
Words fail me.
“i dont notice the color of the games characters, and surely thats the point
and white stereotypes are just as prevelant - the white mass murder, the italian mob boss, the irish boozer, the uk thug/upper class twit, the yank dummy, COD 4 for example was PACKED with stereotypes. why is it acceptable for there to be white stereotypes, but not black ones?”
Well, that settles it then. If a middle-class white guy doesn’t notice any casual racism in games then there can’t be any, can there? And I honestly can’t believe I didn’t notice that every white videogame character was a mass-murderer.
This obsessive hand-wringing need to be politically correct about every little thing is possibly the most tedious facet of modern life.
And yet, I haven’t met a single person who wasn’t bigoted about something. It usually just surfaces somewhere else. Get over it.
This from one of the site’s actual writers. For the love of mothering FUCK.
It’s not nice to realise that world is run largely for your benefit, that as a well-off middle-class man you’ve been born into a position of astonishing privilege through no special merit of your own. That most of mainstream media is designed with your point of view in mind, so that 90% of female characters are fantasy objects and 90% of black characters are capering bloody stereotypes. That’s a really tough thing to come to terms with, largely because we’ve come to accept it as completely normal, as the natural way of things.
Minorites and women have legitimate grievences with the way they’re treated by society and portrayed in the media. It’s annoying to feel you’re being berated for something you, personally, had nothing whatsoever to do with. It’s difficult and, yes, occasionally tedious to consciously avoid bigotry so deeply ingrained in us it’s become part of our language, to consciously try and avoid perpetuating casual racism, sexism or homophobia.
But, y’know? Call me a bastion of bleeding-heart white liberal guilt, but to consider yourself anything even starting to approach a decent human being, I think it’s an effort you’ve got to fucking make.
“It’s not nice to realise that world is run largely for your benefit, that as a well-off middle-class man you’ve been born into a position of astonishing privilege through no special merit of your own.”
true. I found it very sad when presented with the white privilege check-list. It had things on it like “I can be reasonably sure that when talking to a figure of authority, they will be white.” etc very eye opening.
“It’s annoying to feel you’re being berated for something you, personally, had nothing whatsoever to do with.”
I am, however, really sick of hearing how white boys have it rough. It is hard for a tender-hearted person to see how the world is shaped to their advantage. I mean it sucks to be above others… if you are that sort of person (you are
but c’mon suck it up. it is a bazillion times worse to actually be oppressed. To not report rape because you know nothing will happen, to know that there are some neighbourhoods you shouldn’t walk in after dark NOT because of violence but because you will be harassed by police for being black in affluent society.
besides, I tend to think the soft-hearted male who isn’t wanting to feel ashamed of a society that is designed for his pleasure although it does bother him is rare side especially on the internets. I think those boys got so angry because they like being on top. they like tits and ass everywhere and if women feel marginalized by it too fucking bad. we want boobies! and we like black people portrayed as criminals because it makes us feel better. and we aren’t going to change a fucking thing because we like the power, we like being on top and we like being catered to.
so fuck them.
I felt the exact same way when I first read about male privilege.
I’m definitely not trying to say that “white boys have it rough”. Pretty much exactly the opposite. I just wanted to acknowledge that my gut reaction when I first started thinking about this stuff was a defensive rejection of it. I was saying “Well, it’s not MY fault” as if that absolved me of any responsibility to examine and amend my own behaviour.
What I was trying to say is that I understand that reaction, but that it’s vital to push through it. To “suck it up”, if you like.
I might not have made that sufficiently clear, I kind’ve wrote this jumping about and editing all over the place as I tend to when I’m aerated by a subject.
I think you did make it clear with your closing paragraph :)) I was just talking.
and back when we first started talking about this stuff it wasn’t only “Well, it’s not my fault” that irritated me. It was also the “you’re seeing things, you’re looking for trouble, you’re not rational, none of the women I know complain like you so what is wrong with you” that got to me as hard as it did.
somehow you moved beyond that… if you did want to help you might consider how you were able to move from that position to this. maybe it would help others do the same.
Studying is how I got beyond it. Reading stuff. Realising my gut reaction was just my gut reaction and didn’t actually count for anything. Realising I didn’t have the first idea what I was fucking talking about and so probably shouldn’t be talking until I did.
And yes, I’m thoroughly ashamed of how I treated you. It can come of no surprise that I was young(er) and opinionated and defensive and had a peanut for a brain. I’m really, genuinely sorry.
what did you read?
I was about to type I wasn’t looking for an apology, afterall that was a year and a half ago. But, maybe I did. Maybe I did. So, thank you.
Please note - I still don’t really have the first idea what I’m talking about.
maybe even two years ago!!11 lol oh time
it is a process. I am learning all the time, but please don’t feel you need to know every single thing before you speak up because it is impossible to know every single thing and very important to speak up.
I am very proud of you for speaking up on the message thread. I am sure you made the OP feel less alone.
I don’t want to paint myself as a lone hero taking on the vast crowd of ignorant barbarians, here - there was a sizable minority of people speaking in support of the article, too. It’s just that I found the willful pig-ignorance of the majority one part infuriating to two parts depressing.
Cue the B52s !!!
The love shack is a little old place where we can get together?
No?
Bollocks.
I don’t want to butt in here if this is a private discussion… but the kinds of things you’re talking about, here in the U.S. is called Critical Race Theory.
If you are serious about this topic and don’t mind reading about 200 pages of kinds of things that you are ranting about, I would suggest to you the book “Critical Race Theory” by Richard Delgado.
If it were a private discussion, I might have looked for a better place to hold it than TV’s famous The Internet. (MISTER NOT-AS-SARKY-AS-THAT-SOUNDS FACE)
Thanks for the recommendation, Marc. I’ll definitely have a look at it.
As comments left by gamers go, those are extremely lucid, well made points. Well, they’re written in english and punctuated correctly. Given that every utterance I have ever seen penned online by a gamer has been unintelligible gibberish below the standard of YouTube comments, I am amazed.
Yeah, you really do get a better class of blinkered dimwit at Eurogamer.